x

Start investing with a
free Kristal.AI account.

icon

Simple. Secure.

*Error message

IC Speaks5 Mins Read

Sell in May and Go Away, or Is the Trend Your Friend?

kristal.ai-advisory-letter-banner

The first piece that I am writing in my new function at Kristal AI, and I am already confronted with questions of fundamental importance to every investor who likes to believe in proverbs.

Let me lay out a few things that I found quite remarkable over the past weeks, which I think should be taken into consideration when it comes to asset allocation for the coming months:

1.  S&P reached a new all-time closing high.

The September-December 2018 sell-off lasted 66 days, and we had it all recovered in just 83 days again. I have not found any move in the S&P 500 history until the 1980s where we have recovered such a magnitude drop in such a short amount of time. The last comparable move was in Q3 of 2015, with a 15% drop and a subsequent rally into the end of Q1 2016.

The drivers of the market back then were driven by China, with fears of a rapid slowdown and devaluation, which spooked the market, as well as the anticipated beginning of the Fed tightening cycle. In the end, the Fed started to hike rates, and equities read the news as positive after all, because rising rates must surely mean the economy is doing well. What resulted was a multi-year rally in equities.

sp-index-kristal-advisors
sp-index-kristal-advisors-2

And this time? We observe a big discrepancy between global growth expectations (and sentiment) versus the price action of equities. The sharp rally in bonds, as well as equities at the same time, is a testament to this confusion. Maybe in part, it’s the record number of share buybacks by companies. But for sure the biggest driver has been the reversal of the Fed’s sentiment towards rate hikes in late 2018/early 2019 which has caused this slingshot to move higher.

I can’t help the impression that we may have entered an era where the tail of the risky assets is wagging the dog of monetary policy and not the other way round. It is no longer the fear of what economic growth can do to financial markets, it has reversed to the central bankers and politicians fear of what a sharp correction in the value of financial assets can do to the real economy.

2.  The Q1 US GDP report looked re-assuring at first sight, but when you scratch the surface, not all things are rosy.

(Personal consumption has been weak, gains mainly were driven by trade, market movement +3.2% vs. 2.3% as expected). My interpretation here is, that this GDP report is a consequence – to some extent – of the trade war. Stockpiling of inventories by US importers in 3Q and 4Q 2018 was at record highs in anticipation of further tariffs, as was evidenced by record high warehouse utilization in Q4.

After Trump’s postponement of further delay without action until last Sunday, the runoff in inventories has now found its way into the statistics, painting a positive growth picture. We have also seen the May 3rd release of a new 20yr low in the US Unemployment rate, and at the same time Chicago Fed chairman Charles Evans said at an event in Stockholm, that his concerns on the inflation outlook have mounted, and he “wouldn’t be afraid to act if a rate cut is needed”. The Fed has now clearly switched into the mode of data dependency, and the task of their dual policy mandate (Growth & Inflation) puts them into the uncomfortable position of inactivity since those segments are pulling into different directions.

3. Political risk is back! 

Sunday evening, Trump tweeted that he will impose an increased rate of 25% tariffs on USD 200bn worth of imports from China, citing the lack of progress in trade talks and “erosion of commitments by China”. This was furthermore confirmed by R. Lighthizer on Monday in further comments.

North Korea has tested ballistic missiles over the weekend, and this morning (7th May) I am closely following reports about Iran threatening to exit the nuclear agreement with the US, which was followed by a white house announcement that a U.S. aircraft carrier was deployed to the Persian Gulf region.

4. Last but not the least: Seasonality

This has been studied numerous times, and indeed, as found by Bouman & Jacobsen (The Halloween Indicator, 2001), the markets tend to underperform in the period May-Oct on average compared to the Nov – Apr periods. There are many theories that range from the vacation period in Europe that reduces risk-taking during that time, to better performance especially around November/December due to dearth of IPO and corporate bond issuance. We will not know for sure why, but statistically, it is a significant phenomenon.

So, what does this mean?

Piecing together this 3 ½ piece puzzle (I discount the seasonality a bit here…), what does that mean for my outlook for the coming three to six months?

US Equities have reached an inflection point. Personally, I would like to believe that the market has now formed a triple top, counting the highs from Jan 2018, September 2018 and April 2019, and we enter a correction phase with a 10-15% downside potential (2500-2600 area), before having to make a fresh assessment of the situation then.

The second scenario of a liquidity bubble was driven melt-up of stock prices, that pushes S&P beyond 3,000, can also not be fully ruled out, but both are too close to call right now. I’ll be watching very closely if we can rally back above the 2,960 level on the S&P 500, which would give a good indication.

From an asset allocation perspective, with rates anchored at the short end of the curve in the near term, I prefer to keep a significant portion in fixed income and money market instruments, and remain underweight equities until confirmation of recent mixed signals is reached.

Given a steady rates environment, REITs with a high correlation to interest rates are one of the preferred asset classes. For precious metals, the Dollar Index has broken the 97.00 resistance and stronger Dollar means usually lower Gold and Silver prices. I am watching that space carefully for a great opportunity to increase allocations to precious metals for a longer-term trade. But more on this in the not too far future…

All the best for the week ahead!

Sincerely,

Thomas

Disclaimer

The materials and data contained herein are for information only and shall in no event be construed as an offer to purchase or sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase or sell any securities in any jurisdiction. Kristal Advisors does not make any representation, undertaking, warranty or guarantee as to the update, completeness, correctness, reliability or accuracy of the materials and data herein. All opinions, forecasts or estimation expressed herein are subject to change without prior notice. Kristal Advisors and its affiliates accept no liability or responsibility whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss and/or damages arising out of or in relation to any use of opinions, forecasts, materials and data contained herein or otherwise arising in connection therewith.

Other stories you might like

cross
Change your country to India?

You’re now visiting Kristal.AI Worldwide.
To explore diverse offerings in Indian and global products, select India as your country.

ind

India

hkg

Hong Kong

sgp

Singapore

global

Other
Accredited Investor Declaration

This is offered only to Accredited and Institutional Investors as defined under the Securities and Futures Act, Chapter 289 of Singapore (“Act”), which broadly comprises of regulated financial Institutions, large corporates, high net worth individuals and sophisticated investors.

An Accredited Investor is an individual
  • Whose net personal assets exceed in value SGD 2 million (or it’s equivalent in a foreign currency) with value of his/her primary residence capped at SGD 1 million, or
  • Whose financial assets (net of any related liabilities) exceed in value SGD 1 million (or it’s equivalent in a foreign currency), or
  • Whose income in the preceding 12 months is not less than SGD 300,000 (or it’s equivalent in a foreign currency)

I agree to opt-in as Accredited Investor and will submit required documentation to confirm the same.

< Back Proceed as Private Wealth

Wealth Management Solutions
Accredited Investor Declaration

This is offered only to Accredited and Institutional Investors as defined under the Securities and Futures Act, Chapter 289 of Singapore (“Act”), which broadly comprises of regulated financial Institutions, large corporates, high net worth individuals and sophisticated investors.

An Accredited Investor is an individual
  • Whose net personal assets exceed in value SGD 2 million (or it’s equivalent in a foreign currency) with value of his/her primary residence capped at SGD 1 million, or
  • Whose financial assets (net of any related liabilities) exceed in value SGD 1 million (or it’s equivalent in a foreign currency), or
  • Whose income in the preceding 12 months is not less than SGD 300,000 (or it’s equivalent in a foreign currency)

I agree to opt-in as Accredited Investor and will submit required documentation to confirm the same.

Proceed as Private Wealth

STOCKS

Seamless investing enabled by easy and instant access to a wide range of cross border stocks of acclaimed and high potential companies, handpicked by our expert investment committee.

For investors who desire enhanced returns while co-owning shares of global companies.

*The range of stocks will be made accessible, post login

OVERVIEW

Only the best

A range top performing and high potential stocks carefully selected by our seasoned investment committee

Instant Access

Wide range of global stocks made easily accessible with a single click

Diversity

Companies from varied sectors and fields made available for investment enabling clients to diversify investments and effectively mitigate risks

Innovative

High potential companies leading with disruptive technologies made available to clients enabling them to future proof their investments

THEMATIC STRATEGIES

Enabling clients to invest in trending themes like FAMANGThe FAMANG Kristal invests in Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix and Alphabet’s Google stocks. Assets are carefully chosen by an algorithm in order to deliver a superior returns based on past performance. The strategy is rebalanced every quarter., TECHGlobal Technology ETFs is a genetic algorithmic strategy focussed specifically on the Technology sector., ESGProvides exposure to higher rated environmental, social, and governance (ESG) companies while accessing large- and mid-cap stocks in Europe, Australia, Asia and the Far East., etc. with a single click or just create your own thematic basket.

Future-proof your portfolio and capture emerging investment themes.

*The range of Thematic Strategies will be made accessible, post login

OVERVIEW

Explore and Identify

Select from a range of expertly designed trending and diverse themes

Efficient Execution

Enabling easy exposure to your preferred themes without the hassle and costs of individual security selection and execution

Only the Best

A ready-made collection of Kristals that derive the best of the specific asset class or theme

Unique Mix

An optimised blend of ETFs and individual counters, enhancing efficiency and profitability

Contact our Relationship Manager
ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENTS

Diversify your portfolio with exclusive Private Equity, Pre-IPO deals, VC Funds & other investments like Bitcoin, Gold, Hedge Funds and many more.

Kristal fractionalizes difficult-to-access deals and opportunities.

View Alternative Investments

OVERVIEW

Instant Access

A wide range of alternative asset classes such as Gold, Bitcoins, Hedge Funds and many more; readily made available

Risk Management

Enables investments in diversified assets hence spreading the risk

Easy Tracking

Enables you to get a consolidated view of investments in all assets at one place, hence facilitating easy monitoring and tracking

Exclusive Deals

Access to exclusive Venture Capitalist, Startup as well as pre-IPO investment opportunities

Low Investment Tickets

Facilitates fractionalization of investments in deals

Contact our Relationship Manager
FUNDS PLATFORM

Professionally managed funds with active investment strategies, screened for you by our investment committee to diversify your portfolio.

Enabling clients to access exclusive investment strategies.

View Funds

View Funds

OVERVIEW

Access

Provides Access to Professional Fund Managers

Low Investment Tickets

Facilitates fractionalization of investments in funds

Diversity

A wide spectrum of investment strategies ranging from Arbitrage to Credit to Hedge Funds and many more

Fees

No additional costs are charged by Kristal.AI

Exceptional Performance

Funds with an impressive track record and potential for high profitability

Leverage

Benefits from insights of the expert selection and advisory team

Easy Management

No time consuming management of portfolios

Contact our Relationship Manager
TAILOR-MADE PRODUCTS

Customize products based on your market outlook and specific needs across equities, bonds, gold and more.

For investors looking to enhance portfolio yield based on market views.

*The range of Tailor Made Products will be made accessible, post login

OVERVIEW

Enhanced Earnings

Structures with potential to enhance portfolio yield based on market movements

Customization

Product features can be designed to articulate investor views

Fees

A flat and transparent fee structure like nowhere else

One-Click Access

A single feature ‘Ideas’ enables you to access recently launched and trending market opportunities

Contact our Relationship Manager
BUILD YOUR OWN KRISTAL

Can’t find what you are looking for? Create your own exclusive investment strategy with risk management & periodic reporting.

For seasoned investors who prefer to design their own portfolio.

OVERVIEW

Empowered Investing

Enables clients to create their own custom portfolio based on their unique needs

Unlimited Choice

Access to all possible exchange traded assets

Flexible Management

Flexibility in delegating the portfolio management role to us or actively taking up the day to day investment decisions, in your custom Kristal

Custom Fee Structure

A simple, transparent and a customized fee structure

Access to Expertise

Custom performance reporting as well as advisory support

Contact our Relationship Manager